Israel Fact Check

NYC's Mamdani Praises Terror Financiers, Spreads Genocide Lies

6/27/2025 | Updated 7/1/2025

Key Facts to Counter Terror Support and Genocide Lies

1. The Holy Land Five were convicted of providing material support to Hamas terrorists, not humanitarian aid. Supporting terror financiers undermines legitimate Palestinian causes.
2. Genocide requires intent to destroy a group entirely. Gaza's population has grown from 265,000 in 1967 to over 2 million today - contradicting genocide claims completely.
3. Israel provides medical care, electricity, and humanitarian aid to Palestinian civilians. No genocidal regime provides life-saving assistance to their alleged victims.
4. Jews survived actual genocide for millennia, including the Holocaust. Accusing genocide survivors of genocide is a cruel historical inversion that dishonors real victims.
5. Israel warns civilians before military operations and provides evacuation routes. Genocidal regimes don't warn their intended victims to flee to safety.
6. Hamas explicitly calls for Jewish genocide in their charter while using civilian shields. The actual genocidal intent comes from Israel's enemies, not Israel.
7. Israeli Arabs serve in the Knesset, Supreme Court, and military with full citizenship rights. Genocidal states don't integrate targeted groups into government.
8. Terror financing enables attacks on innocent civilians. Praising those who fund terrorism legitimizes violence against both Israelis and Palestinians.
9. Misusing genocide accusations trivializes actual genocides and dishonors Holocaust survivors and other victims of real genocidal campaigns throughout history.
10. Political leaders who praise terror financiers and spread genocide lies contribute directly to rising anti-Semitic violence in communities worldwide.

Critical Alert

NYC Assembly member Zohran Mamdani, running for mayor, praised convicted terror financiers in his rap "Salaam" and spreads false genocide accusations against Israel. This dangerous combination of terror support and anti-Semitic lies has contributed to the alarming rise in anti-Jewish attacks across New York City.

When political candidates like Zohran Mamdani publicly praise convicted terror financiers and spread false genocide accusations against Israel, they cross a red line that should disqualify them from public office. In his rap "Salaam," Mamdani expressed "love to the Holy Land Five" - individuals convicted in federal court of providing material support to Hamas terrorists. This is not legitimate political discourse but dangerous extremism that legitimizes terrorism and spreads anti-Semitic hatred with real-world consequences for Jewish communities.

The Stakes in NYC

New York City is home to the largest Jewish population outside of Israel, with over 1.1 million Jewish residents. Anti-Semitic incidents in NYC have increased dramatically, with politicians who praise terror financiers and spread genocide lies directly contributing to this climate of hatred. When mayoral candidates legitimize terrorism and anti-Jewish propaganda, they create a dangerous environment for Jewish New Yorkers.

Mamdani's Praise for Convicted Terror Financiers

The Holy Land Five: Convicted Terror Financiers

In 2008, five individuals were convicted in federal court for providing material support to Hamas, a designated terrorist organization:

  • • Operated a charity that funneled millions to Hamas
  • • Supported an organization that murders Israeli civilians
  • • Received sentences ranging from 15 to 65 years in federal prison
  • • Were found guilty after extensive FBI investigation and federal trial

In his rap "Salaam," Mamdani called out "my love to the Holy Land Five," expressing solidarity with individuals who were convicted of financing terrorism. This is not a case of civil rights advocacy or supporting the wrongly accused - these individuals were found guilty in federal court of providing material support to Hamas, a terrorist organization responsible for murdering thousands of innocent civilians.

The Holy Land Foundation case was one of the largest terrorism financing prosecutions in U.S. history. The defendants were not convicted for providing humanitarian aid, as their supporters claim, but for deliberately funneling money to Hamas through a network of front organizations. The evidence presented at trial included recordings of the defendants discussing their support for violent resistance and their knowledge that their funds were supporting terrorism.

By praising these convicted terror financiers, Mamdani is not advocating for Palestinian rights - he is legitimizing terrorism and the murder of innocent civilians. This represents a fundamental moral failure that should disqualify any candidate from public office in a democracy that opposes terrorism.

The Legal Reality: What Genocide Actually Means

Beyond his support for terror financiers, Mamdani has also spread false genocide accusations against Israel. The United Nations Genocide Convention, established in 1948 specifically in response to the Holocaust, defines genocide as acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group. The critical legal element is intent - the deliberate purpose to eliminate a group of people entirely.

When we examine the actual facts on the ground, the evidence completely contradicts genocide accusations against Israel. The Palestinian population in Gaza has grown from approximately 265,000 in 1967 to over 2 million today - one of the highest population growth rates in the world. This demographic reality alone makes genocide claims factually impossible.

Legal scholars and international law experts have consistently noted that military conflicts, even those involving civilian casualties, do not automatically constitute genocide. The intent requirement is paramount, and Israel's documented efforts to minimize civilian casualties - including warning systems, precision targeting, and humanitarian assistance - directly contradict any claim of genocidal intent.

The Connection Between Terror Support and Anti-Semitic Lies

Mamdani's combination of praising terror financiers and spreading genocide lies is not coincidental - it represents a coherent anti-Semitic worldview that legitimizes violence against Jews while simultaneously accusing them of the very crimes being committed against them.

Hamas, the terrorist organization that the Holy Land Five supported, explicitly calls for the genocide of Jews in its founding charter. The 1988 charter quotes the Protocols of the Elders of Zion and calls for killing Jews wherever they are found. Even the revised 2017 charter, while moderating some language, still refuses to recognize Israel's right to exist and maintains the goal of destroying the Jewish state.

Hamas's Genocidal Agenda

The organization Mamdani's praised financiers supported explicitly promotes:

  • • Killing Jews worldwide, not just in Israel
  • • Destroying Israel entirely, not seeking coexistence
  • • Using civilian shields to maximize Palestinian casualties
  • • Rejecting all peace negotiations and compromise solutions
  • • Promoting anti-Semitic conspiracy theories and Holocaust denial

When politicians like Mamdani praise those who finance such organizations while simultaneously accusing Israel of genocide, they are engaging in a particularly vicious form of projection. They support actual genocidal terrorists while accusing their victims of genocide - a cruel inversion of reality that has deep roots in anti-Semitic propaganda.

Historical Context: The Pattern of Anti-Semitic Inversion

The accusation of genocide against Israel, combined with support for those who finance anti-Jewish terrorism, represents one of the most cruel inversions in modern political discourse. Jews have been the targets of systematic extermination attempts for over two millennia, culminating in the Holocaust where six million Jews were murdered in an industrialized genocide.

Historical Pattern of Anti-Semitic Accusations

  • • Medieval blood libels: Accused Jews of murdering Christian children
  • • Economic scapegoating: Blamed Jews for financial crises they didn't cause
  • • Conspiracy theories: Accused Jews of controlling world events
  • • Modern inversion: Accusing genocide survivors of committing genocide

This pattern of accusing Jews of the very crimes committed against them has deep historical roots. Throughout history, Jews have been falsely accused of the crimes their persecutors were committing. Today's combination of genocide accusations with support for terror financing follows this same template of projection and inversion.

The establishment of Israel in 1948 represented the fulfillment of the Jewish people's right to self-determination and a refuge from millennia of persecution. Many of Israel's founders were Holocaust survivors who had experienced actual genocide. To now accuse this haven of committing genocide while supporting those who finance terrorism against it represents a particularly vicious form of anti-Semitic propaganda.

Comprehensive Evidence Against Genocide Claims

The factual record provides overwhelming evidence that contradicts genocide accusations against Israel while revealing the actual genocidal intent of the terrorists Mamdani's praised financiers supported:

Demographic Evidence

Palestinian population growth contradicts genocide claims:

  • • Gaza: 265,000 (1967) → 2+ million (2024)
  • • West Bank: 585,000 (1967) → 3+ million (2024)
  • • Israeli Arabs: 160,000 (1948) → 2+ million (2024)
  • • Among world's highest population growth rates

Terror Financing Impact

The Holy Land Five's financing enabled:

  • • Suicide bombings against Israeli civilians
  • • Rocket attacks on Israeli cities
  • • Murder of Palestinian peace activists
  • • Suppression of Palestinian civil society

Israeli Humanitarian Measures

Israel provides extensive assistance:

  • • Medical care in Israeli hospitals for Palestinians
  • • Electricity and water infrastructure
  • • Emergency medical evacuations
  • • Coordination with international aid organizations

Integration Evidence

Arab citizens participate fully in Israeli society:

  • • Knesset members and Supreme Court justices
  • • Military officers and government officials
  • • University professors and business leaders
  • • Full voting rights and civil liberties

The contrast could not be clearer: Israel takes extraordinary measures to protect civilian life and integrate Arab citizens, while the terrorists financed by the Holy Land Five explicitly target civilians and suppress Palestinian voices for peace and coexistence.

Real-World Consequences of Terror Support and Genocide Lies

When politicians like Mamdani praise terror financiers and spread genocide lies, the consequences extend far beyond political rhetoric. These actions contribute directly to violence against Jewish communities and undermine legitimate efforts for peace.

Measurable Impact on Jewish Safety

  • • FBI data shows Jews remain most targeted religious group (60% of religiously motivated hate crimes)
  • • NYC anti-Semitic incidents spike during periods of anti-Israel rhetoric
  • • Synagogue vandalism and physical attacks on visibly Jewish individuals
  • • Jewish students face harassment and intimidation on college campuses
  • • Jewish families avoid displaying religious symbols in public

The correlation between political rhetoric that legitimizes terrorism and actual violence against Jews is well-documented. When politicians praise those who finance terrorism while spreading genocide lies, they create a permission structure for hatred and violence.

Moreover, this rhetoric undermines genuine peace efforts. Palestinians who seek coexistence and oppose terrorism are marginalized when politicians praise terror financiers. Israelis who support peace initiatives are discouraged when faced with genocide accusations. The actual result of Mamdani's rhetoric is to make peace less likely and violence more probable.

The Normalization of Anti-Jewish Hatred in Politics

Mamdani's combination of terror support and genocide lies would be immediately recognized as disqualifying if directed at any other group. Imagine the reaction if a political candidate praised financiers of anti-Black terrorism while spreading lies about African genocide. Yet anti-Jewish hatred has become normalized in ways that other forms of racism have not.

This normalization has ancient roots - anti-Semitism is called "the world's oldest hatred" because it has persisted across cultures, religions, and political systems for over two millennia. Unlike other forms of racism, anti-Semitism has adapted to every political movement, from ancient paganism to medieval Christianity to modern progressive politics.

Double Standards in Action

Consider how similar rhetoric would be treated if directed at other groups:

  • • Praising financiers of anti-Black terrorism would end any political career
  • • Spreading genocide lies about African nations would be universally condemned
  • • Supporting those who finance attacks on Muslim civilians would be criminal
  • • Yet praising anti-Jewish terror financiers is treated as "legitimate criticism"

This double standard reveals the anti-Semitic nature of Mamdani's positions. Jews are held to impossible standards while those who attack them face no consequences. When politicians can praise terror financiers and spread genocide lies without political consequences, it demonstrates how deeply anti-Semitism has been normalized in American politics.

Fighting Back: Zero Tolerance for Terror Support

Combating politicians who praise terror financiers and spread genocide lies requires treating such positions as the extremism they represent. This is not about stifling legitimate political debate - it is about maintaining basic standards that prevent the normalization of terrorism and anti-Semitism.

Essential Actions

  • • Expose the truth about convicted terror financiers
  • • Document the connection between rhetoric and violence
  • • Hold politicians accountable for extremist positions
  • • Support Jewish communities facing increased threats
  • • Educate voters about the consequences of electing extremists
  • • Build coalitions opposing all forms of terrorism and hatred

Political accountability is crucial. Voters must understand that candidates who praise terror financiers and spread genocide lies are not engaging in legitimate political discourse - they are promoting extremism that threatens public safety and democratic values.

Educational efforts must focus on the facts: the Holy Land Five were convicted of financing terrorism, not providing humanitarian aid. Israel is not committing genocide - the demographic evidence, humanitarian measures, and military conduct all contradict such claims. Meanwhile, the terrorists these financiers supported explicitly call for Jewish genocide.

New York City's Choice

New York City faces a clear choice in its upcoming mayoral election. The city can choose leaders who oppose terrorism and protect all residents from hatred, or it can elevate politicians who praise terror financiers and spread anti-Semitic lies.

The Jewish community in New York has contributed immeasurably to the city's success. From building neighborhoods to creating businesses, from advancing science to enriching culture, Jewish New Yorkers have helped make NYC one of the world's greatest cities. They deserve leaders who will protect them from terrorism and hatred, not politicians who legitimize both.

Moreover, all New Yorkers should recognize that supporting terrorism and spreading hatred threatens the fundamental values that make the city work. When politicians can praise terror financiers without consequences, it signals that extremism is acceptable in American politics. This threatens everyone's safety and security.

Conclusion: Rejecting Extremism in American Politics

Zohran Mamdani's praise for convicted terror financiers in his rap "Salaam" and his spread of false genocide accusations against Israel represent exactly the kind of dangerous extremism that has no place in American politics. These are not policy positions worthy of debate - they are expressions of hatred that contribute directly to terrorism and violence against Jewish communities.

The Holy Land Five were convicted in federal court of financing Hamas terrorism. Hamas explicitly calls for Jewish genocide and has murdered thousands of innocent civilians. By expressing "love" for those who financed such terrorism, Mamdani has disqualified himself from any position of public trust.

His simultaneous spread of genocide lies represents a cruel inversion of historical reality. Jews have been the victims of actual genocide for millennia, and Israel serves as a refuge from such persecution. To accuse genocide survivors of committing genocide while praising those who finance terrorism against them represents a particularly vicious form of anti-Semitic propaganda.

The facts are clear, the stakes are high, and the choice is obvious. Politicians who praise terror financiers and spread anti-Semitic lies must face the same consequences as those who promote any other form of extremism. Democracy requires rejecting such hatred at the ballot box.

New York City deserves leaders who oppose terrorism and protect all residents from hatred. Zohran Mamdani has chosen to praise terror financiers and spread anti-Semitic lies instead. The choice for voters is clear: reject extremism and choose leaders who will keep all New Yorkers safe from terrorism and hatred. The safety of Jewish communities - and the integrity of American democracy - depends on it.